Need opinions on downsizing / selling guitars

edited March 2014 in Root
Every so often I go through a phase where I feel like purging some instruments that I don't use, however I know once their gone I'll probably regret it. It's not like I have too many, just 4 electrics and one acoustic. However, out of those 5 guitars, I play two of them about 95% of the time.

This weekend I played a mid 70's thinline Gibson 175. I was digging it, but the 2k price tag was making me balk, especially since I have a hard time justifying spending that kind of cash when I'm no longer in a gigging band that occasionally brings home some cash. Selling a guitar or two to finance the purchase could help take the sting out, but up until now I've avoided doing that because I didn't want to feel the regret of letting one go, even though it might be one that I don't play. One of mine that especially bothers me is a mid 70's Guild acoustic. It's a decent guitar, but a bit tough for me to play. There's probably some bluegrass picker out there that could get on with it better than me. I struggle selling it because it was my first good guitar and I'm hung up on this thing about not wanting to part with something that has a little value and is "vintage". I'm getting to the point though where I feel like it's time to move on and own guitars that I dig playing, and that fit with my current interests vs. just maintaining a collection for the sake of it.

Anyone else struggle with this stuff???

Comments

  • Don't sell your first nice guitar! I have a clunky american sunburst strat that I saved all summer for when I was 16. I never ever play it anymore but would never want to part with it. I know if I did i would really regret it.

    As for how many guitars to keep around, I debate this all the time. I have two teles that 100% of my play time goes into. I also have a guild hollowbody that I keep because it looks really cool and a fender lead 2 from the 70's that was my uncles when he was a teenager.

    Ideally I would want to great electrics and an acoustic. That would cover all I need.

  • Aside from money... my criteria questioning selling...

    Do I play it?

    Will I ever be able to get it again - and if not, can I live with that?



  • I subscribe to the theory that guitars should be played and not sit in a case for years. Like Toy Story for guitars. There is someone out there that might play the hell out of the guitar I'm not using. That being said, I still have too many guitars. I also completely understand keeping anything that has sentimental value or uber vintage value.
  • edited March 2014
    What JC posted- that's exactly what I ask myself. Especially the 2nd part of the last question.

    I own 7 guitars, and truth be told, if the house were burning down, there's only one that meets all the criteria, and I would grab before all else: my #1 tele. The others I keep for sentimental reasons (from my "band" days, I've had them 30 years now), or don't play them that much, or I do play them, but aren't "married" to any of them. Nice guitars, fun to play, but not my "desert island" guitars.

    I could get rid of ALL my acoustics (I have 3) if I could find THE ONE acoustic for me...
  • Which model mid 70s Guild acoustic are you talking about?
  • Thanks for the comments guys. BTW Campinout, it's a `75 Guild D40. Good guitar but certainly no pre-war Martin. I could definitely pick up another one down the road if I really felt the need (of course, it wouldn't be MY old Guild but whatever!).
  • I would say keep the Guild unless the neck is so skinny you can't even play it. Some Guilds are like that but definitely not all. Some people like the skinny neck. Also anyone buying a Gibson make absolutely sure you know what you are buying. There has been a recent surge of imported counterfeits.
  • I've bought and sold guitars more than I've played them... or so it seems to me now that with 2 small kids it seems that I never play anymore.

    Anyway, maybe I just should venture out ( = fork out) more, but I think I miss sold amps more than the guitars. And for those I also think that equally good or even better is out there.

    I have two electric and one acoustic now, btw. a cheapo Squier Vibe tele being the one I play 90% of the time. It's not perfect, but certainly more perfect than I am, for sure.

    My first guitar was a Yamaha C40, I sold it after 10 years. Was quite glad that the guy that I sold it to agreed to sell it back to me at a fair price like 5 years later, so I gave it as a xmas present to my brother-in-law. So, I get to see it and reminisce once or twice a year. That's nice, sure, but not essential to me in any real way.
Sign In or Register to comment.